Fanindra Nath Bose holds the distinction of being the first Asian artist to be elected to the Royal Scottish Academy. He was also the first Indian sculptor to gain recognition in Great Britain.
Born on 2 March 1888 at Bohar, Dacca, East Bengal,[1]Bose undertook his early studies at Calcutta’s Jubilee Art Academy, established in 1897 by students in protest at the western-focussed teaching of the Government Art School which they attended. [2]
At the age of 16 Bose left India for Italy to continue his studies. That proved unsuccessful and he came to Edinburgh via London.
In 1905, Bose was successful gaining admission to the Edinburgh School of Art (formerly the Trustees’ Academy) whose classes were held in the Royal Institution Building on The Mound (which would become the Royal Scottish Academy building). In 1906, Bose then entered the RSA Life School, where in 1907 he was joint winner of the annual Stuart Prize awarded by the RSA to the best figure drawing by a student of either the Life School or the Edinburgh School of Art.[3] Amongst Bose’s fellow students at the Life School was the sculptor George Henry Paulin.
In 1908 Bose became one of the first cohort of students at the newly opened Edinburgh College of Art (ECA). There he continued under the tutelage of Percy Portsmouth (1874-1953), who was appointed Head of Sculpture and had already recognised Bose’s talent whilst teaching at the School of Art. In his obituary of Bose, Portsmouth wrote; Bose excelled in small sculpture; he had a phenomenal control of minutia. It was most interesting to watch his beautiful hands manipulate his tools, he was an exquisite craftsman, a true artist, showing delicacy and taste in everything he did.
Bose graduated from ECA in 1911 with a Diploma in Sculpture andwas awarded a £100 travelling scholarship from the College He is known to have been in Paris by September 1911, visiting also Versailles, and in Rome, Florence and Naples in 1912.[4]
On the continent he made pencil drawings of sculptures which he encountered - described as some of the finest things he ever produced. In France he made sensitive studies of 17th century statuary at the Palace of Versailles as well as more contemporary pieces. He appears to have been particularly attracted by the work of Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux and of Rodin whose The Kiss and Age of Bronze he sketched. The influence of Marius-Jean-Antonin Mercié has also been noted. Sketches of mediaeval carvings on the facades of French cathedrals including Tours, Amiens and Reims were probably made from casts seen at the Musée de la Sculpture Comparée in the Trocadero, or in the Louvre..[5]He also appears to have attended life classes at Antoine Bourdelle’s Académie de la Grande Chaumière in 1911.[6]
He was also reputedly introduced to Auguste Rodin, then the grand master of French sculpture, who was greatly impressed with Bose’s work. Their contact is said to have lasted from 1912 to around 1915.[7] By this time Bose was back in Edinburgh and working under Portsmouth at ECA. On 15 April 1915 at 24 York Place, Edinburgh, Bose married Mary (Molly) Buchan Fergusson.[8]
In 1915 Bose was appointed Sculptor to his Highness Sir Sayajirao Gaekwad III (1863-1939) the Gaekwar of Baroda in Gujarat, India and undertook a visit back to the country of his birth. [9]Bose was commissioned to execute a series of eight bronze figures of national historical personages of Baroda for the Lukshmi Vilas Palace gardens in Vadorada and two bronze statuettes for the Baroda Art Gallery. These last two works may be the pieces shown by Bose at the RSA Annual Exhibition in 1918 and which would appear to have been cast in Edinburgh.[10] Bose was also the advisor to the Gaekwar for the technical schools in Baroda, where it was intended to develop bronze casting, and where he taught briefly. The Maharaja had earlier purchased a copy of Bose’s The Hunter which he had seen in the collection of Sir William Goscombe John RA the Welsh sculptor. John had purchased a cast of it from Bose via the Royal Academy exhibition in 1916, having also acquired his 1914 exhibit there Boy in Pain.[11]Regarded as perfectly cast and imbued with the sense of continuing movement and surface texture which mark Rodin’s sculpture as so revolutionary, Bose’s work is now regarded as that of the first modern Indian sculptor.[12]
By 1916 Bose had established his own studio at 4 Belford Road in Dean Village, which was by then a hive of ateliers and workshops.[13]
Bose’s surviving public art in Scotland are memorials in bronze to the fallen of the First World War. Photographs in the RSA Archive suggest he was responsible for the plaque commemorating 80 employees of the Wm Younger & Co. Ltd’s Brewery at Holyrood.[14]He sculpted the figure representing the sacrifice of youth, which stands atop Ormiston War Memorial in East Lothian and is suggestive of Rodin’s Age of Bronze. The most impressive however is his his life-size bronze figure of St John the Baptist which forms part of his War Memorial Shrine in St John’s Parish Church, Perth. Sir Robert Lorimer was the architect of its major refurbishment as Perth’s Memorial to the fallen of the First World War in the 1920s. Lorimer, who often worked closely with artists to decorate his spaces, may have been the catalyst in securing Bose the commission. Unusual in its scale (Bose was renowned for his small sculptural pieces) it clearly shows the influence of Rodin in the textured surfaces of the figure of St John.[15]
At the General Assembly of the RSA on 18 March 1925 Bose made history on being elected an Associate Academician (ARSA). He was first proposed in 1924 by Pittendrigh Macgillivray RSA. In the final round of voting, Bose secured 31 votes, his challenger for the vacancy in the Associate Sculptor ranks was Benno Schotz with 8.[16]At a Scottish Arts Club gathering to honour Bose and his fellow new Associates, Bose referenced the strain between India and Britain and felt that his honour would help to ease this and would be accepted as much by his countrymen as by him.[17]
Bose was very much a sculptor on the rise exhibiting at the RA, RSA, RGI and the SSA.[18] but his promise was cut short after he suffered a fatal cardiac arrest whilst on a fishing holiday at Laverlaw Farm near Peebles, on 1 August 1926.[19]
Bose was buried in an unmarked grave at Liberton Cemetery, his funeral attended by a strong number of his fellow Associates and Academicians including the architect Sir Robert Lorimer and fellow sculptors Portsmouth, Alexander Carrick and Charles d’Orville Pilkington Jackson.[20]
In 2013 Bose’s grave was identified and a modest plaque was cut in marble by Edinburgh sculptor Kenny Munro, in the hope that it may be a temporary marker pending a more imposing memorial.[21]
- Robin Rodger, Documentation Officer
[1] Information from the artist’s family
[2] RSA Annual Report 1926. This short-lived Academy closed in 1927 so unable to verify. Typed autobiographical notes (private collection) state that he enrolled there aged 14.
[3] RSA Life School Records 1858-1911, and RSA Annual Report, 1907. Bose passed most of his annual examinations with first class rating as evidenced in the annual examination results posted in the Edinburgh Evening News (2 August 1905) and The Scotsman (11 August 1906 and 1 August 1907). Fellow students included Pilkington Jackson, G H Paulin, Stanley Cursiter and A B Thomson all of whom would go on to be elected to the Royal Scottish Academy. In 1908 Bose was awarded a silver medal in the National Art Examinations for his model of a figure from the antique, as well as a book prize (The Scotsman, 25 July 1908).
[4] Details from Bose’s student record, ECA Archives. Also The Scotsman, 1 August 1911 and 27 August 1912. In 1910 Pilkington Jackson was the sole recipient of a Diploma in Sculpture from ECA, the Edinburgh Evening News (9 August 1910) reporting that Bose and Paulin had also reached Diploma standard but the award had been deferred until completion of the qualifying stages of the other sections, this being a condition on which the Diploma was awarded.
[5]The RSA Collections hold four of Bose’s Sketchbooks (2024.0069.86-.89 inc.) which contain bound sketches of such works. Their sequencing in the sketchbooks coupled with the lack of any other depictions of the cathedrals per se or the towns in which the cathedrals stand, alongside the precise manner in which they are titled, strongly suggests that he was not working from the carvings in situ in their original settings.
[6] One drawing in RSA Colls (2024.0069.51) is inscribed “Academie de la Grande Chaumoir”[sic] where Antoine Bourdelle was a key figure. Bourdelle and Rodin were close friends and this may be how Bose came to Rodin’s attention. Again there is no extant record of Bose’s attendance at the Academie (e-mail corres RSA-Musee Bourdelle, Paris, Sept 2024).
[7] Bose stated in typed autobiographical notes (private collection) “…..while in Paris, met the late M.Rodin, the great French sculptor, who took great interest in my work. E-mail corres RSA-Musee Rodin, Paris Sept 2024 has found no archival evident to support this however Percy Portsmouth’s carte de visite survives in the Museum Archives. Another potential introduction may have been the Welsh sculptor Sir William Goscombe-John who was one of the external assessors for Bose’s finals at ECA. Goscombe-John subsequently purchased both of Bose’s Royal Academy exhibits and is known to have shown these to the Maharaja of Baroda on one of his regular trips to the West and who subsequently acquired a cast of one of them also. The Maharaja appointed Bose his official sculptor in 1915. The Scotsman reporting on the General Assembly of the RSA (10 March 1927) stated; “While in Paris as a travelling student he had the advantage of an introduction to M. Rodin, the great sculptor, who took a keen interest in his work, setting him tasks to do, criticising the results, and giving him great encouragement. Rodin insisted on a high standard, demanding absolute adherence to and detailed rendering of the form and character of the model.”
[8] Statutory Marriage Registration, per Scotland’s People online portal. One of the witnesses was fellow sculptor David Francis. Molly was housekeeper to the widowed Mrs Galloway and her two young children, the elder of whom, Leslie, sat to Portsmouth as a means of securing some income. Molly would take and collect Leslie from the sittings and first met Bose in Portsmouth’s studio at ECA. Portsmouth’s work “Cupid” was not exhibited and is untraced.
[9] Details from Bose’s student record, ECA Archives.
[10] RSA Annual Report 1926, Bose’s Obituary notice, also Maholay-Jaradi, Priya: Fashioning a National Art, Oxford University Press, 2016.
[11] The two works purchased by Goscombe John are in the collections of the National Museum of Wales, which has kindly lent one of them, The Hunter, to this exhibition. The other, Boy in Pain was subsequently exhibited at RSA (1915) and RGI (1918) as Boy and Crab.
[12] Paromoo, Ratan, “Fanendranath Bose : The Neglected Expatriate Sculptor”, Asian Arts Archive, viewed on-line at cdna.aaa.org.uk, also Singh, Nihal, “A Bengali Sculptor Trained in Europe” in The Graphic, 1 May 1920 which illustrates 6 of the 8 bronzes commissioned for Baroda.
[13] RGI Annual Exhibition Catalogue, 1916, index of exhibitors.
[14] The plaque has since been removed from the Holyrood Brewery site and placed on an outer wall of the Canongate Kirk.
[15] The casting was undertaken by Charles Henshaw & Son in Edinburgh (Perthshire Advertiser, 31 October 1928). It is unclear whether Bose lived to see it cast, but it was not installed until the week of 13 September (Perthshire Advertiser, 22 September 1926). Henshaw also cast the memorial plaque in Campbeltown to the Reverend G W Strang. Henshaw is credited in the newspaper coverage of its unveiling in 1924 as having designed and executed it however a sepia photograph of it found in one of Bose’s sketchbooks suggests that Bose was possibly responsible for the portrait profile. Henshaw is also the likely contender for casting the Younger’s War Memorial plaque.
[16] RSA General Assembly Minute Book 24 November 1891-20 March 1940, (RSA Archives 1.11.6.4)
[17] The Scotsman, 19 March 1925, RSA Newspaper Cuttings Book 1924-1928, RSA Archives
[18] Bose showed his Boy with Crab and Athlete and Hound at the 5th Annual Exhibition of the Glasgow Society of Painters and Sculptors in Glasgow’s McLellan Galleries in 1923 (Aberdeen Press and Journal, 19 March 1923). He also had 2 works lent to the 13th Annual Exhibition of the Society of Eight in Edinburgh in 1925 (Edinburgh Evening News, 6 January 1925).
[19] Statutory Death Registration, per ScotlandsPeople online portal
[20] The Scotsman, 5 August 1926, RSA Newspaper Cuttings Book 1924-1928, RSA Archives
[21] Letters Munro-RSA, RSA Archives. By 2024 the plaque has been reported by Munro as missing.